Could this right-hander’s spot in the SF Giants’ rotation be in jeopardy?
- Right-Handed pitcher Jordan Hicks struggled in his ninth start for the San Francisco Giants on May 14, 2025, at Oracle Park.
- Hicks entered the rotation after spring training but has faced difficulty replicating his strong March 31 debut, when he struck out six and allowed no earned runs.
- On May 14, Hicks lasted just over two innings, allowing five earned runs and seven hits before being replaced by right-hander Hayden Birdsong, who gave up a three-run homer.
- Hicks’ season record is 1-5 with a 6.75 ERA, the fifth-highest among 108 MLB starters with at least nine starts, highlighting a steep decline from his 4.07 ERA in 2024.
- Manager Bob Melvin and team management may consider moving Hicks from the rotation to the bullpen, with Birdsong and Kyle Harrison as potential rotation replacements.
10 Articles
10 Articles

Could this right-hander’s spot in the SF Giants’ rotation be in jeopardy?
SAN FRANCISCO – Jordan Hicks had lost six straight decisions as a starting pitcher last season when the Giants decided to move the right-hander from the rotation to the bullpen. With wins once again proving to be elusive for Hicks in 2025, manager Bob Melvin could soon be tempted to make a similar move. Hicks, making his ninth start of the season on Wednesday, didn’t pitch poorly but was still charged with five earned runs on seven hits in what …
Where Giants' rotation stands after Hicks' shortest start of '25
SAN FRANCISCO -- The Giants have largely resisted the urge to shake things up amid tough stretches this year, but they’ve reached the point where they may have to consider making a notable change to their starting rotation. Jordan Hicks lasted only two-plus innings in an 8-7 loss that sealed
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 88% of the sources are Center
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
Ownership
To view ownership data please Upgrade to Vantage