Shelby Nealy Gets Death Penalty in 2018 Triple Murder of Wife's Family in Tarpon Springs

Tampa Bay Man Who Killed Wife, Then Murdered His In-Laws to Cover Up the Crime, Gets Death Penalty

Shelby Nealy, 32, was sentenced to death over the slayings of his wife's parents and her brother in an attempt to cover up his earlier murder of his wife.

Family Killer Sent to Death Row: ‘Forfeited His Right to Live’

Shelby Nealy, who pled guilty to the murders of his wife’s parents and brother, has been sentenced to death. While handing down the sentence, the judge noted that Nealy “forfeited his right to live.” Nealy killed his wife, Jaime, in Jan. 2018 and posed as her by sending texts and pictures of their two children to her family. However, when Jaime’s family grew suspicious, Nealy traveled to the family’s home and killed her parents, Richard and Laur…

Shelby Nealy gets death penalty in 2018 triple murder of wife's family in Tarpon Springs

A Pinellas County judge sentenced Shelby Nealy to death for the brutal murders of his then-wife’s parents and her brother.