CS Lewis' Family 'Very Upset' at Meryl Streep as Aslan, Friend Says: 'Going to Destroy the Brand'
Christian critics say the casting departs from C.S. Lewis’s theology and could damage the franchise’s brand, as the film heads for a 2027 release.
- Netflix confirmed last week that actor Meryl Streep will voice Aslan in director Greta Gerwig's The Magician's Nephew, drawing sharp criticism from Christian readers who argue casting a woman as the Christ-like lion departs from Lewis' theology.
- Critics argue that because Aslan represents Jesus, gender-swapping the character is 'theologically' incorrect and problematic. Movieguide founder Dr. Ted Baehr called the casting a 'tremendous heresy,' warning it could 'destroy the brand' of Narnia.
- Friends of Lewis' family claim relatives are 'very upset' by the decision and are attempting to regain control of the Lewis Company. The Holy Post Podcast co-host Phil Vischer questioned if Aslan will be a 'male lion with a woman's voice.'
- Director Greta Gerwig envisions her adaptation as 'a rock opera,' having previously described feeling alienated by 'God the Father' imagery. Baehr questioned whether she possesses the biblical worldview to faithfully adapt the material.
- Some critics on social media have nicknamed Streep's version 'Tashlan,' referencing a demonic character from Lewis' The Last Battle. The film is scheduled for a February 2027 theatrical release amid ongoing debates.
18 Articles
18 Articles
Hollywood Doesn’t Believe In Evil Anymore
I don’t know who decided 2026 was the year we’d destroy every great work of literature with a Hollywood adaptation, but boy, are we in deep. Most of us have already (thankfully) forgotten about the BDSM atrocity that besieged us in February in the form of “Wuthering Heights,” and while Nolan’s “Odyssey” was a decent standalone film, it did little justice (at least in my view) to Homer’s original creation. The internet’s been abuzz this past week…
Meryl Streep as Jesus Is Hollywood's Latest Idea
Conservatives expressed grave concern when director Greta Gerwig happily announced that her forthcoming movie “Narnia: The Magician’s Nephew” would star Meryl Streep as the voice of Aslan—the lion that author C.S. Lewis clearly used as a Christ figure. This kind of gender confusion gives off vibes of James Talarico announcing that God is “nonbinary.” She’s...
C.S. Lewis' Family Reportedly 'Upset' Over Choice of a Female Aslan - Charisma Magazine Online
One of the biggest rumors surrounding film director Greta Gerwig’s upcoming “Narnia” movie has now been confirmed: Meryl Streep will voice Aslan. That’s sparking accusations of “gender-bending” a character who is widely regarded as a Christ figure. Gerwig revealed the casting in an interview with Empire, explaining why she chose the legendary actress to portray […]
Greta Gerwig, to the realization of this megaproduction at 280 million dollars, wanted to appeal to an actress over 70 years of age, "who has a presence without taking himself too seriously".
Hollywood Feminist Makes Over Jesus to Sound Like Meryl Streep
Screenshot of Colbert interview from Snapstream/CBS Conservatives expressed grave concern when director Greta Gerwig happily announced that her forthcoming movie Narnia: The Magician’s Nephew would star Meryl Streep as the voice of Aslan – the lion that author C.S. Lewis clearly used as a Christ figure.This kind of gender confusion gives off vibes of James Talarico announcing that God is “non-binary.” She’s giving Narnia a “rock opera” makeover,…
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 67% of the sources lean Right
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium
