"I Put My Foot Down": Chad Michael Murray's Surprise Decision Totally Changed 'One Tree Hill'

"I Put My Foot Down": Chad Michael Murray's Surprise Decision Totally Changed 'One Tree Hill'

Some casting decisions are literally so good they feel like fate, which is the case for a lot of our favorite teen dramas. Can you imagine anyone besides Leighton Meester playing Blair Waldorf? Or anyone besides Adam Brody as Seth Cohen? If you ask us, all of One Tree Hill's characters are just as perfect. The core cast of the show (Sophia Bush as Brooke, Bethany Joy Lenz as Haley, Hilarie Burton as Peyton, Chad Michael Murray as Lucas, and Jame…