Judge Rules Against Proposed Lawsuit over Commercials on Amazon Prime
WASHINGTON STATE, UNITED STATES, JUL 15 – Judge Barbara Rothstein ruled ads on Prime Video were a permitted modification under subscriber agreements, dismissing claims that the $2.99 monthly ad-free fee was an unlawful price increase.
- On July 16, 2025, U.S. District Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein dismissed the lawsuit filed by Washington state Prime Video subscribers, citing permitted benefit modifications.
- When Amazon launched its ad-supported Prime Video in January 2024, charging $2.99 monthly to opt out, subscribers argued that this breach their expectation of an ad-free service.
- Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein described the benefit modification as permitted under the subscriber agreement, while Prime customers voiced objections, calling it unfair and disruptive.
- The ruling leaves dissatisfied Prime Video users without compensation, as Amazon doesn’t have to refund those upset about ads, according to the judge.
- It remains uncertain whether similar lawsuits could emerge in other jurisdictions, leaving subscribers with limited legal options.
27 Articles
27 Articles

Amazon wins in court: A class action against more advertising at Streamer Prime Video has been dismissed – the additional 2.99 euros remain.
Class-Action Lawsuit Over Amazon Prime Video Ads Tossed by Judge
A federal judge dismissed a class-action lawsuit filed against Amazon by disgruntled customers who alleged the company had deceived and cheated them by introducing ads into Prime Video unless they paid extra. U.S. District Court Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein of the Western District of Washington on July 16 granted Amazon’s request to dismiss the consolidated class-action complaint. First, Jacobs Rothstein cited the court’s prior ruling conc…
Class-Action Suit Against Amazon For Putting Ads On Prime Video Dismissed By Federal Judge
A federal judge in Washington state has dismissed a class-action lawsuit against Amazon for putting ads on Prime Video. In a ruling issued Wednesday (read it HERE), U.S. District Judge Barbara J. Rothstein rejected the claim that Amazon’s decision to start running ads in 2024 effectively represented a price increase for Prime members. Only by […]
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 55% of the sources are Center
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium