A-List Pop Star Was American Idol's 'Top Pick' for Judge Before Carrie Underwood

A-list pop star was American Idol's 'top pick' for judge before Carrie Underwood

AN A-list pop star was American Idol’s ‘top pick’ to be a judge before casting Carrie Underwood, The U.S. Sun can exclusively reveal.  Despite ABC execs having their eyes set on a certain Hollywood icon, the star’s alleged “ridiculous” salary demand ultimately ended up squashing the deal.  GettyCarrie Underwood celebrates Ladies Night on American Idol[/caption] GettyLuke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie judge American Idol[/caption] Car…

'American Idol' Execs Make Decision On Carrie Underwood Return For New Season

Carrie Underwood first came to fame by winning the fourth season of American Idol. Twenty years later, she returned to the show as a judge for Season 23. As the season recently came to an end, fans are wondering if she will only be a one-season wonder. Recently, an inside source weighed in on whether she will be returning. Carrie Underwood Made Her Return To American Idol After Around 20 Years Underwood first appeared on American Idol as a conte…